Coverage.com Car Insurance Review: Consumer Reviews and Quotes (2025)

Coverage.com is an online insurance agency that serves customers in all 50 U.S. states and Washington, D.C. It generates both real-time quotes and offers for auto insurance products. Once you answer several questions, the site will provide you with personalized options from well-known car insurance companies.

Here’s what you need to know about Coverage.com and its offerings.

Coverage.com at a glance

Coverage.com aims to match drivers with car insurance options from reputable insurers, such as Nationwide, USAA, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, and State Farm. It “believes in empowering and providing people with the insurance knowledge they need when it matters most.”1

Coverage.com earns money through commissions and advertising, according to its website.

How does Coverage.com work?

Coverage.com is similar to other comparison sites in that it asks you to share basic information about yourself and the vehicle you want to insure. Its questionnaire includes questions about the details of your vehicle, the average annual mileage, and your preferred coverage options.

Once you complete the form, you’ll receive a combination of real-time quotes and offers. However, its offers are essentially advertisements instead of actual insurance quotes based on your unique situation.

If you’re interested in an offered quote and want to move forward with a policy, you’ll need to go to the insurer’s website and share your details again to buy it. Note that a live agent is available throughout the process to provide assistance and answer any questions you might have.

Coverage.com reviews: What real customers are saying

Coverage.com has minimal reviews online. On Trustpilot, it earned a rating of 2.5 out of 5 based on five reviews.2 Most of the complaints state that the website doesn’t provide actual car insurance quotes. Reviewers mention that they have to fill out the same information multiple times and that the entire process wasn’t worth it. 

At the time of writing, there were no reviews of Coverage.com on Google or the Better Business Bureau.

Coverage.com vs. Insurify

Insurify is a digital insurance marketplace that allows users to instantly compare car insurance rates from several companies. Unlike Coverage.com, all users receive accurate quotes for liability coverage or full coverage in real time without any offers or ads. Insurify also partners with more than 100 national and regional insurers.

While Coverage.com focuses on car insurance, Insurify also provides quotes for other types of insurance coverages, such as home insurance and life insurance. In addition, Insurify differs from Coverage.com in that it doesn’t require you to share your information twice. If you’d like, you can finalize your insurance policy directly on its website.

Is Coverage.com a spammy site?

Coverage.com is transparent about how it uses customer information. Its privacy policy states that it may share your data with third parties and Red Ventures’ sister websites. It may also use your information to perform market research, run sweepstakes, show location-based ads, and send messages via email and social media.

The good news is that Coverage.com allows you to fill out a form and opt out of the sale or share of your personal information.3 All you have to do is provide your name and email address.

Coverage.com FAQs