Homeowners insurance covers the cost of repairing or replacing your home or personal property after certain kinds of damage. But how much your insurer pays toward those costs depends on your home’s calculated value and the type of coverage you purchase.
Replacement cost value is the amount of money it would cost to replace your home or your personal property with a comparable home or personal property. The market value of a home is the amount of money it would sell for on the open market.
Learn more about the difference between replacement cost and market value, as well as some other types of home insurance coverage, so you can choose the right policy for your needs.
Replacement cost defined
Replacement cost value, or RCV, is the cost to restore your home to its pre-damage condition or, if it was destroyed, replace it using comparable materials.
Take the structure of your home, for example. Homeowners insurance usually covers the dwelling’s replacement cost, so if your home is destroyed in a fire, the insurance company will pay to rebuild it using the same type and quality of materials that the original had.1 And it’ll do so even if your home was worth less when it was destroyed than when you insured it.
Replacement cost insurance is optional when it comes to insuring your personal property, such as clothings, electronics, and furniture. If you choose RCV and lightning causes a power surge that destroys your 20-year-old washer, the insurance company will replace the destroyed machine with a brand-new one of a similar size and style.
Factors that affect replacement cost
Several factors determine how much it would cost to replace your home, including:2
Square footage
Age
Fixtures
Design
Home features
Foundation type
Market value defined
Market value is the price a buyer would pay for your home or land on the open market. A home’s market value could be more or less than its replacement cost, depending on the current real estate market.
The market value of personal property doesn’t really come into play for insurance purposes. Rather, insurers tend to look at actual cash value of possessions.
While your home itself might be worth more now than when you first insured it, personal property usually depreciates in value. That depreciated value, also called the actual cash value, or ACV, is what the insurer uses to calculate your reimbursement.
To see how much of a difference that can make with personal property, refer back to the previous example of the 20-year-old washing machine destroyed by a lightning strike. If the insurance company determines that its depreciated value was only $50, that’s all it’ll reimburse you for.
That means you’ll have to pay the difference between the $50 reimbursement and the cost of a new machine.
Factors that affect market value
Market value is based on the closed-sale prices of similar homes. It compares factors such as location, size, condition, improvements, and the home’s features. Market value also considers the value of your land and the local school districts.
Market value is often more relevant to personal property than the home itself, which usually has replacement cost coverage. An exception to that rule is an older home that was built using materials or to standards that are obsolete or too expensive to use in the rebuild.
That type of home might have HO-8, or modified form, coverage that usually only reimburses market value.
How to calculate the replacement cost of your home
To calculate the replacement cost of your home, you need professional knowledge of construction processes as well as material and labor costs. It’s nearly impossible for a homeowner to gather that information on their own.
Insurance companies typically use a replacement cost estimating software to calculate the costs. Elements of the reconstruction include square footage, the year built, architectural style, the number of stories, foundation and roof construction, kitchen and bathroom fixtures, and size and type of garage, according to CoreLogic, a real estate data and technology company.
Construction costs change over time, and as a result, so do replacement costs. So unless you have HO-8 modified form insurance, your insurance will pay the replacement cost of your home.3 You should review your policy each year to make sure you have enough replacement cost coverage.
Pros and cons of insuring at replacement cost
Most homeowners insure their homes for replacement cost. Consider these pros and cons of replacement cost insurance:
How to calculate the market value of your home
If you’re about to purchase a home using a mortgage loan, or you just recently financed a home purchase, your lender’s appraisal will tell you the current market value. Otherwise, you’ll have to hire an appraiser to find out the market value.
Appraisers have the tools, training, and license required to calculate your home’s fair market value — or the price a consumer would pay for it on the open market.4
An appraiser determines the market value by comparing your home to similar homes that have recently sold. They research market conditions and compare the home’s location — and other details like the home’s style, features, and condition — to other area homes.
Then, using your property as the reference, the appraiser adds to and subtracts from the comparable properties’ sale prices based on whether your home compares more favorably or less favorably on many different factors.
The appraiser documents all this information on a Uniform Residential Appraisal Report. Home values change all the time, so keep in mind that your home’s market value changes, too.
Pros and cons of insuring at market value
Even though replacement cost makes sense for most homeowners, in some situations you might have good reason to insure at market value. But before you do, consider the advantages and disadvantages.
Other types of home insurance coverage
Standard replacement cost coverage isn’t the only kind of coverage available, and in some cases, it can leave you underinsured if the cost to repair or replace your home exceeds your dwelling coverage limit. Consider whether these alternative or additional coverages might better protect your investment:
Replacement cost vs. market value FAQs
The type of coverage you choose to insure your home can have major financial consequences if you have to repair or replace your property due to damage — especially if you need to rebuild your home. Consider this additional information before choosing the best coverage for your needs.
Does the amount of replacement cost coverage you choose affect your home insurance premium?
Yes. Standard replacement coverage generally costs less than extended replacement cost coverage or guaranteed replacement cost coverage.
Is a home’s replacement cost higher or lower than its market value?
Your home’s replacement cost is generally lower than its market value. But many variables can affect a home’s value, like the cost to rebuild, its location, and the current real estate market.
Is it better to have actual cash value or replacement cost?
In general, it’s better to have your home and property insured for their replacement cost instead of actual cash value. Actual cash value factors in depreciation and may not be enough to cover the cost to repair or replace your home.
How much home insurance coverage do you need?
Experts recommend insuring your home for at least 80% of its replacement cost. But insuring your home for its full replacement cost value will provide the most protection.