How and When to Self-Insure Your Home

Home insurance rates are up 6% in 2024 and 20% in the last two years, according to Insurify data. These dramatic rate increases are due to several factors, including natural disasters and inflation. And, with home insurance rates on the rise, it’s no wonder homeowners and renters alike are looking for more affordable ways to protect themselves and their belongings.

Depending on your financial situation, self-insurance may be the way to go.

Self-insurance is setting money aside in a savings account, or withdrawn from your investments, to cover expenses that homeowner or renters insurance would normally reimburse you for. This could include items damaged on your property.

Here’s what you need to know about self-insuring your home.

Homeowners self-insurance explained

A homeowner is self-insured if they decide to forgo traditional homeowners insurance coverage and instead use their financial reserves to cover unexpected costs, repairs, and emergencies. Choosing to self-insure can help cut insurance costs, as you’re no longer paying an insurer for a policy.

The key difference between self-insurance and traditional homeowners insurance is who’s responsible for out-of-pocket costs. Self-insurance relies on you having the income or financial resources — including money in savings or funds you can withdraw from investments — to pay for repairs should anything happen to your home.

For example: If you experience water damage in your home and need to replace your flooring, you could be out up to $5,000 to fix the floor alone.1 If you had homeowners insurance, you’d be responsible for your deductible, which is $1,000 on average for customers with a traditional policy. This would amount to up to $4,000 of savings, minus the money you spent paying your monthly insurance premium.

Find Your Next Home Insurance Policy

Search rates from top insurers

Enter your ZIP codeView My Quotes

Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.

Based on 7,669+ reviews

4.8/5

Who can self-insure — and who can’t

Self-insurance isn’t an option for everyone. But it could be right for you if you:

• Are a high-income household and are close to retirement

• Have more disposable income and no dependents

• Own your home outright

• Have enough financial reserves to cover any unexpected expenses, repairs, or other costs

Self-insurance may not be an option for you if:

• You don’t own your home outright and are carrying a mortgage, as your mortgage company will require you to carry homeowner insurance to protect its interests

• You don’t have the financial resources to cover emergencies in real time without going into debt

• You aren’t a high-income household

How homeowners self-insurance works

If you decide to self-insure your home, you’ll want to have an adequate savings account you contribute to regularly. This could be an emergency fund housed in a high-yield savings account or an investment account you can access quickly, such as a mutual fund. If something happens to your home, instead of filing a claim, you’ll need to tap into your savings to cover the expense yourself.

Pros and cons of self-insuring your home

Is self-insuring your home right for you? Here’s a list of advantages and disadvantages to consider.

How to self-insure your home

If you decide the self-insurance route is right for you, you’ll want to take the following steps to make sure you have adequate coverage.

1. Calculate the value of your home both inside and out. It’s important to not only know the value of your home but to also know the value of the belongings inside. You should list electronics, art, jewelry, appliances, furniture, and other family heirlooms of significant value, and you should update this list regularly.

2. Estimate potential repair and replacement costs. To adequately self-insure your home, you must understand your potential repair/replacement costs. Rates for repairs and replacement items can vary widely among home improvement stores and contractors, but calling around or searching the web can give you a general idea. Next, don’t forget potential medical bills in case someone is injured in your home and you’re legally required to cover it.

3. Determine your self-insurance amount. Once you’ve done your research, it’s time to decide how much you should save to help protect yourself. A good idea might be to set your figure as a certain percentage of your belongings or the value of your home.

4. Open a high-yield savings account (HYSA). HYSAs offer a higher annual percentage rate than traditional savings accounts and are easy to access when needed.2 With a high interest rate, your money will be making you money in no time.

5. Make monthly payments into your savings account. Once you’ve figured out your account goal, make saving toward it a regular part of your budget. You can dedicate a certain percentage of your income or a predetermined amount to regularly be sent to your designated savings account. Eventually, you’ll get used to the money transferring directly to your account and won’t miss it in your daily life.

When to make adjustments to your self-insurance

Choosing to self-insure isn’t a decision you make and then forget about. Instead, choosing to self-insure requires you to take a more active role in protecting yourself against any future potential financial losses.

You should sit down at least twice a year and re-evaluate your home’s value and the value of your possessions. These evaluations may show that you need to put more money aside than you originally thought — or your possessions could depreciate, meaning you could lower the amount.

Find Cheap Home Insurance

Check quotes from 120+ top insurance companies

Enter your ZIP codeView My Quotes

Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.

Based on 7,669+ reviews

4.8/5

Alternatives to homeowners self-insurance

The option to self-insure your home isn’t practical for most homeowners. But that doesn’t mean there aren’t other ways you can save on homeowners insurance policy and lower your premium.

Here are a few options you could consider:

Homeowners self-insurance FAQs